The European Union's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) entered its definitive phase on 1 January 2026, requiring importers of iron and steel, aluminium, cement, fertilisers, electricity and hydrogen to account for embedded emissions. For India, whose steel and aluminium exports to the EU are substantial, CBAM raises pressing questions of legality and strategy. This paper asks whether CBAM can be justified under Article XX of the GATT 1994 and what recourse India has. It argues that CBAM is best defended under Article XX(g), with Article XX(b) a weaker alternative, but that its vulnerability lies at the chapeau, in three implementation features: the default-value and verification regime, the asymmetric recognition of carbon prices paid abroad, and limited differentiation for developing countries. The paper then assesses India's options in light of the EU–India free trade agreement concluded in January 2026, which grants no CBAM exemption, and the WTO panel established in September 2026 in DS639, in which India is a third party. It contends that litigation offers India limited practical value while the Appellate Body remains inoperative, and that a combined strategy of third-party engagement, negotiated recognition of India's Carbon Credit Trading Scheme and verifiers, and prompt completion of domestic carbon pricing is more promising. The paper concludes with recommendations for Indian policymakers.
Foreign exchange reserves constitute an essential component of the "international monetary and financial system", enabling central banks to maintain external payment capacity, support exchange-rate stability and strengthen confidence in national economies. Traditionally, reserve management has been guided by the principles of safety, liquidity and return. However, increasing geopolitical tensions and the use of financial sanctions have exposed vulnerabilities in the accessibility of sovereign reserves held through foreign financial institutions. The immobilisation of Russian foreign exchange reserves following the conflict in Ukraine demonstrates that the security of reserve assets depends not only on their financial quality but also on the jurisdictional, institutional and geopolitical conditions governing their custody and utilisation. This article examines the changing dimensions of reserve security by analysing the relationship between geopolitical sanctions, international financial intermediaries and central bank reserve-management strategies. It evaluates the implications of foreign-held reserve immobilisation for custodial arrangements, currency diversification, cross-border payment infrastructure and global financial stability. The study argues that conventional reserve-management frameworks do not sufficiently recognise geopolitical accessibility as an independent dimension of reserve security. It proposes an analytical framework incorporating financial, operational and geopolitical security and recommends stronger geopolitical risk assessment, diversified custodial arrangements, institutional accountability and contingency planning. The article concludes that incorporating geopolitical considerations into reserve-management practices is necessary to strengthen the resilience of sovereign reserves and maintain confidence in the international financial system.
In Laksh Vir Singh Yadav v. Union of India, the Delhi High Court decided a batch of over thirty writ petitions by persons whose names, tied to old judicial records and news reports, kept surfacing in name based searches long after the proceedings had ended. Sachin Datta J held that the right to be forgotten is a facet of informational privacy under Article 21, enforceable by writ even against private search engines and legal databases, but that the remedy is de-indexing from name based results and, in suitable cases, masking of identifiers, not deletion of the record. Relief is channelled into defined categories, chiefly acquittal, discharge or quashing, settlement, and purely private disputes. This comment argues that the central distinction between a record's existence and its retrievability by name is sound, but that the framework relies on outcome based categories, builds a right through adjudication while Parliament has declined to enact one, draws support from an intermediary rule that presupposes the order sought, and contemplates de-indexing across all versions of a search engine without a developed comparative justification. Its durability also depends on pending Supreme Court proceedings.
In State of Kerala v. M/s Panacea Biotec Ltd., the Supreme Court restored a prosecution for misbranding a pentavalent vaccine under the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940, which the Kerala High Court had quashed because the Magistrate did not hold the inquiry required by section 202 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. The Court held that limitation under section 469(1)(c) runs from the date on which the offenders' identity is established through the inspector's verification, and that a complaint by a public servant in discharge of official duty is not vitiated by want of a section 202 inquiry. It also held that whether directors are in charge of a company under section 34 of the Drugs Act is a question of fact for trial. This comment argues that the reasoning on limitation sits uneasily with the offender specific wording of section 469, that reading section 200 into section 202 conflates two different safeguards, and that substituting accused persons twenty years after the events raises fairness questions the Court left unexamined.
In Sabita Paul v. State of West Bengal, the Supreme Court restored the anticipatory bail of a mother accused of helping her son blackmail a neighbour with obscene photographs. The High Court had cancelled the bail because she suppressed her earlier failed attempts to obtain it. The Supreme Court did not address the suppression. It reasoned that the principal accused, her son, already enjoyed bail, that her role was only to further his acts, and that parity therefore required equal relief. This comment argues that the decision usefully confirms that parity turns on the role of each accused, but leaves three questions open: the effect of suppression on the exercise of discretion, the assumption that custodial interrogation is unnecessary in a case resting on electronic evidence, and the absence of protective conditions for the complainant.